Charlie McManus has spent his life chasing one goal: to become a Major League Baseball player. But for his best friend, Daniel Hollignsworth, his future—working for his father on Wall Street—was set in stone long before his first breath.

On New Year’s Eve, a reckless dare lands them behind bars with Harrison Price, a free-spirited graffiti artist and rebel among Manhattan’s elite. When Harrison proposes a kiss at midnight, none of them could have imagined that ringing in the new year together would feel so good.

What was meant to be a fleeting encounter in the city that never sleeps quickly turns into an unexpected and unconventional relationship when their paths cross again. In a world where conformity reigns, Charlie, Daniel, and Harrison must decide whether love is shaped by fate or simply the choices they’re willing to make.

Only one thing is for sure…in the game of love, tagging bases isn’t as easy as it seems.